Sam wiped the cum he just sprayed into the back of Stephanie’s ass until it was nothing more than a clammy patch of skin and then collapsed on top of her back. She told him he had to pull out. She wasn’t on birth control anymore since she’d started having issues with drops in her blood pressure. Sam kept thinking he should really wear a condom, but it’s so hard to go back once you’ve fucked without one. He couldn’t imagine being attached to Stephanie for the rest of his life should they make a mistake. He’d already came inside her once while they were drunk, and she hit him with this gem of a line when she was late on her period later that month, “You know, I feel like I’m at the point in my life where I could really have a child. Don’t worry. You don’t have to help if you don’t want to.”
Sam couldn’t fathom not helping out if he did get her pregnant. He knew he could be a good dad, but he certainly wasn’t ready. He spent most nights drinking till sunrise with or without the help of a few twenties of cocaine. Not to mention the thousands of dollars of debt. And even if he wasn’t completely immature and irresponsible, he didn’t want to have a kid with Stephanie.
It was funny. There was a time when he couldn’t imagine not spending the rest of his life with her. Now, he spent most of his days fretting over how to get away from her. He knew this wasn’t healthy. Fucking his ex-girlfriend. And not just any ex-girlfriend, the one who broke his heart the first time. The one who fucked Sergio, his best friend at that point since grade school. The one who sent him on this whole downward spiral of drug and alcohol abuse in the first place.
Despite all the guilt and shame over letting Stephanie back into his life, Sam still felt like he needed her right now. She took care of him in a motherly sort of way that no real girlfriend would ever put up with. She drove him home when he got too drunk, took his shoes off before she put him to bed, poured him a glass of water if he wasn’t unconscious already, and a lot of times she’d even blow his flaccid whiskey dick even when she knew there was no way he’d be able to hop on top of her in that condition. And he was still so lonely from losing Beth, he just, well, he needed Stephanie even if most of the time they spent together aside from the sex felt like his brain was being scrubbed with a piece of steel wool.
He knew the routine though. He wrapped his arms underneath her and cradled her as he kissed her cheek. She turned her neck towards him and between heaves of breath said, “I love you.”
She’d said it every time they’d fucked since they’d ran into each other again on the patio at Lola’s. It had been a couple of years since he’d last seen her, and he was drunk, and this time for whatever reason, he didn’t get up and walk away when she sat down. She gave him what he felt was a fairly heartfelt apology, and then offered him a no strings attached session of fucking for after the bar. It had been six months since Sam had gotten laid, since Beth and he had fucked the last time on a drunken night a couple months after they broke up. The loneliness was killing Sam. He didn’t even have a stupid crush to fantasize about, and he was so desperate for a woman. He went back home with Stephanie, and he didn’t remember much of that night after the bar, but he remembered her saying, “I love you.”
He said it back the first time. He’d said it back a few times actually, but she said it every time. It had been two months since they had hooked up again. They’d spent almost every night together even though this was supposed to be a strictly fuckbuddies type of arrangement, and every fucking time, except for the one’s on drunken blackout nights Sam couldn’t remember, he was sure she said it at least once. Most of the time, he just smiled or pretended not to hear her. When it was really great sex, he’d get caught off-guard and reciprocate. For whatever reason, this time he asked about it, “Why do you have to say that?”
“I don’t know. I mean, I do.”
“It’s weird is all.”
“I think I’m still in love with everyone I’ve ever been in love with. I don’t think it goes away.”
Sam gritted his teeth a little bit when he heard her. Because getting back together with her had stirred some of these same emotions in him. It had been years since she’d broken his heart, and staring at her when she said that made him feel that time when he thought she was the most perfect specimen of human female he’d ever laid eyes upon. He decided to say it back again, “I love you too, I guess. It’s just weird, you know?”
“Why?”
“Well, I don’t know, well, I mean…”
“Because of Sergio?”
As she said his name, Sam felt something vile enter his stomach through his esophagus. It was the hatred. She was one of only two people Sam could ever say he truly hated. Apparently, the hatred didn’t go away either. He wanted to forgive her. He’d guessed he had, but this whole situation just didn’t feel appropriate. He felt like it was the perfect opportunity to tell her he didn’t want to do this anymore, but then again, where else would he be able to find someone he was so sexually compatible with who would put up with his drinking? He decided to just say, “Yeah.”
“Look, what we did to you was awful, and a part of me will always feel like a terrible human being, but it doesn’t mean I didn’t love you. Even when I was doing it.”
“I know. I know. And I’m over it. Mostly. It’s just, well, it’s just weird. I don’t know what else to say.”
“Sam, let’s not talk about this right now. Will you just hold me?”
They rolled over and Stephanie pressed her back into Sam’s stomach as he put his right arm around her stomach and cupped her right breast with his left arm. He thought again about the whole pregnancy scare they’d just gone through last month and wondered if maybe he wished she had gotten pregnant. Maybe it would be time to get his shit together. He wondered if he’d try to get back with her for real if it happened. Maybe she was the best he could do. Maybe a mistake that she made had altered the course of their destiny together. Maybe this was a second chance. After a few minutes of silence, Sam whispered into Stephanie’s ear, “What are we doing here?”
“What do you mean?”
“I mean, this, us, what are we doing?”
“We’re just fucking and hanging out.”
“We’ve spent every day together.”
“Yeah, I wonder about that too, but I’m having fun and I don’t know. I don’t really want to stop.”
“I know. I don’t either.”
“So let’s just leave it at that.”
“I just want to make sure you don’t want it to be more or anything.”
“Sam, I’ve already been your girlfriend. I’d really like someone new, but that isn’t seeming to happen for me, and you’re great for in the mean time.”
“So, I’m just some fucking replacement then?”
“Don’t get mad. That’s not what I’m saying. Look, you know we wouldn’t work together together.”
“And I don’t want to get back together.”
“So, why are you acting all offended?”
Sam breathed a sigh. He wasn’t sure why he was either. He felt the same way. Maybe that was why. Their connection at this stage in his life felt so strong. Like they were on the same page in so many ways, and yet, all the wrong ways. It seemed like the last two years of his life had been spent suffering all the shit that comes from loving the wrong people, and he just wanted someone new, but he didn’t want to be lonely more. Insert Stephanie. He looked back at her as her face stared inquisitively and intently at him waiting for a response. He just shrugged his shoulders before saying, “I don’t know.”
They just laid there for a few more minutes without talking again before Sam looked at the clock and noticed it was ten-thirty. His crew would be showing up to the bar soon. He heard Stephanie’s heavy breaths, and whispered, “You awake?”
“Yeah.”
“Look, I gotta go.”
“Are you pissed off?”
“No, I gotta go meet Joey at the bar.”
“Can I come?”
“I thought you had to work in the morning.”
“Not that early. Besides, I won’t drink too much. Do you not want me there?”
He didn’t. Not really. Joey didn’t like Stephanie. He was Sam’s other best friend. He had been there for the whole Sergio/Stephanie debacle years before and had listened to Sam’s crying and cursing over the whole thing. Every time Sam brought Stephanie back around, he could feel Joey’s disapproval each time he caught his eyes while they spoke, but Stephanie would always drive his car if he got too fucked up, which happened most nights. The relief of the stress of not having to drive home especially when he already had a DWI on his record was worth the leers Joey gave them.
“No, it’s fine. Come on. Put some clothes on, and hurry up. I need a drink.”